Thanks for the quick reply, Jim! Very helpful.
I agree that option 1 is closest to what I have going (same storyform with two different players as MC).
Following up on that: If I'm using the same storyform, then both MCs would have the same Issue, Problem, Solution, etc, correct? And would the ICs for each MC also have the same Issue, Problem, Solution, etc?
I can see the flexibility with Dramatica and how you could create two very different characters out of the same set of Story Points.
But that leaves me with one other question: does that mean both MCs would have to have the same Resolve/Growth? Or could one be Changed, the other Steadfast? (Which is what I was thinking, but now seems muddled if I'm only using one storyform.)