Just going from memory I would agree with you – I feel like I’m more looking “at” Giselle with all her crazy birds and things. And doesn’t she do some decoration with the curtains that we don’t see until Patrick Dempsey does, and we’re surprised along with him? (Or maybe that was Sound of Music lol)
That said, I haven’t listened to the podcast or seen the movie in a while, so take it all with a grain of salt.
As I was thinking about this I was wondering about another possible test we could use: Possible MC vs. IC test