New films for analysis?

[TerryVog]

There are a few movies I would like to suggest, either because they are personal favourites or they would resonate well with the story I'm trying to write:
1. Cashback (2006)
2. Peaceful Warrior (2006)
3. Money Monster (2016)
4. The Wolf of Wall Street (2013)
5. Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (2010)

[MWollaeger]

Haha, Cashback always shows up on my Netflix as Recommended, but besides that I've never heard of it.

I'm pretty sure that Money Monster is a tale -- think of how preachy it is.

[TerryVog]

You are probably right about Money Monster. But you should totally see Cashback. It is lesser known, but it is a gem (imho).

[Khodu]

Hi Guys. Was wondering why we haven't done the Hunger Games or Maze Runner or Divergent yet?
These are highly successful movies and books. It beats my imagination that we haven't done those here yet. Just saying.

[MWollaeger]

Have you read the books themselves? I only ask because "Ender's Game" is pretty clearly a GAS in the book, but not in the movie. I'm curious which medium would be the best choice for these.

[Khodu]

Yeah it is. The Book for Enders Game is definitely complete. The Movies for me. Not everyone here has or might read the books. The movies however may offer some lessons for all. For me personally I would like to see how us Dramatica users would review those movies. I've seen the reviews of other paradigms. Truby and co. Lets break them down shall we?

[bobRaskoph]

I can see the success in Hunger Games, but as far as I know, neither Divergent nor Maze Runner (the movies) were all that well received, and not just for being YA adaptations. Box Office success is a different matter, as Cameron's Avatar was the most financially successful movie in recent history, but the story...?

So yeah, I would like to see a breakdown of Hunger Games, even if it wasn't to my liking. Someone outside this community has done a superficial Dramatica Analysis before, but his other breakdowns (of Frozen and Fault in Our Stars) were heavily contested by the resident Dramatica Experts, so take it with a huge grain of salt.

[mlucas]

@Jhull is discussion of whether nominated films are potentially complete GAS's on-topic for this thread? Or should we be creating separate thread(s)?

[MWollaeger]

I tend to post whether or not I think things are not a GAS because I don't want the community wasting their time analyzing something that works (or doesn't) based on storytelling alone. There is value in understanding why a movie like Don't Breathe or It Follows works, but it's not for this thread or for the Monthly Users Group Analysis.

If you want to discuss whether or not something is a GAS, I guess I would start a new thread, because it's going to get into analysis and that can take up a bunch of space.

[MWollaeger]

I'm going to leave it to Chris to put (or not) the movies into the Users Group.

[mlucas]

Makes a lot of sense, thanks Mike. I created a new thread called Hunger Games, Divergent, Maze Runner complete stories?

[MWollaeger]

Jim, after the selection, we may want to close this thread and start a New New Films for Analysis.

[jhull]

Great idea! As soon as we figure out films for 2017...

[Prish]

Could we add "Lincoln" as a current year suggestion before this thread is closed? It strikes me as maybe a perfect storyform, as did A Man For All Seasons. I thought it would have been suggested, before now, but my searches on this forum and on the Dramatica webpage turn up nothing for it, but not so expert here.

[HaroldLloyd]

1. Any "OS Concern = Contemplation" movies. 12 Angry Men & The Client are the only 2 such analyses that I've found.
2. Little Miss Sunshine
3. The Miracle Worker (1962)
4. A Man Called Ove
5. Other People's Money (1991)
6. October Sky (1999)
7. Stand and Deliver (1988)
8. The Killing Fields (1984)
9. Doctor Zhivago
10. Midnight Run (1988)

[Prish]

Midnight Run might be another perfect storyform. That would be fun. It's one of my most favorite movies!

[MWollaeger]

Can I ask that people use the new thread for new suggestions?

[Prish]

So, if we have comments about any of the films already mentioned in this thread, do we post them on this old thread, or on the new one?

[MWollaeger]

Start a new thread for comments. This isn't a discussion thread, just a recommendation thread. Same for the new incarnation.

Chris already went through this theead for movies, so it's been retired.

[jhull]

2 posts were merged into an existing topic: DUG Potentials for 2017